The Argument Against CA Prop 8
I could vote NO on Proposition 8 because I have gay friends and relatives who would want me to. I could vote NO on Proposition 8 because I don’t care that much if gay people get married because it doesn’t really affect me directly. But those reasons are the weak side of the argument.
Most of the Prop 8 supporters that I know want to see gay marriage overturned because they are opposed on religious grounds. Gay marriage makes them uncomfortable. According to the Bible, they say, it’s wrong. One friend actually whipped out the “next they’ll be marrying horses and dogs” argument. She’s intelligent. I was pretty shocked.
The NO on Prop 8 campaign today announced that the secret $1 million donor to Prop 8 has been revealed: Alan Ashton, of Lindon, Utah. According to the Deseret News, Ashton is a Mormon and grandson of David O. McKay, President of the Mormon Church from 1951-1970. Ashton made his fortune in software.
The major force behind the proposition is church groups. No real surprise there except that our state, our country, has as a fundamental tenet: freedoms shall not be limited by a tyranny of the majority. John Stuart Mills famous essay, “On Liberty,” argues that:
Like other tyrannies, the tyranny of the majority was at first, and is still vulgarly, held in dread, chiefly as operating through the acts of the public authorities. But reflecting persons perceived that when society is itself the tyrant — society collectively over the separate individuals who compose it — its means of tyrannizing are not restricted to the acts which it may do by the hands of its political functionaries. Society can and does execute its own mandates; and if it issues wrong mandates instead of right, or any mandates at all in things with which it ought not to meddle, it practices a social tyranny more formidable than many kinds of political oppression, since, though not usually upheld by such extreme penalties, it leaves fewer means of escape, penetrating much more deeply into the details of life, and enslaving the soul itself. Protection, therefore, against the tyranny of the magistrate is not enough; there needs protection also against the tyranny of the prevailing opinion and feeling, against the tendency of society to impose, by other means than civil penalties, its own ideas and practices as rules of conduct on those who dissent from them; to fetter the development and, if possible, prevent the formation of any individuality not in harmony with its ways, and compel all characters to fashion themselves upon the model of its own.
In fewer words, it’s wrong to allow the majority to dictate their morality onto others when the majority suffers no injury from the minority. Don’t take away liberty just to assuage your own discomfort with people who are different from you!
The line between church and state is functional and appropriately drawn in this argument. If your church chooses NOT to sanctify gay marriage, great. That’s a religious choice. But if the state discriminates against gay marriage on religious grounds, something’s gone very wrong. The California Supreme Court ruled in favor of gay marriage for the right reasons. The law recognizes the needs and fundamental LEGAL rights of these individuals to enter into a binding contract known as “marriage.” For financial reasons. To own joint property. For medical benefits, and death benefits, and parental rights, and for all the reasons that straight people get legally married.
If your only argument against gay marriage is religious, it’s time to admit you’re making a mistake. On election day, do the right thing for other human beings who deserve the same legal rights as you. Vote NO on Prop 8.
Possibly Related Posts:
- With Freedom and Liberty for All
- Free Range Kids, or Not…
- Go for the Cash! (Or Stay in for the Long Haul?)
Comments
16 Responses to “The Argument Against CA Prop 8”
Leave a Reply
-
-
About
Welcome to duh pookie where we work hard to bring you sparkly new thoughts.
-
- RSS Feed
-
Visit Political Voices of Women Community
UdvYCliW ugg slippers FwlAYmgR uggs on clearance SriEYioY http://uggsaleuk.webeden.co.uk EbwHHvmM discount ugg boots FbnUGpiW
7YylZ8DjjI8 uggs on sale for women 6IopN9OagM7 uggs on sale
oVvmBhfZv ugg boots sale iGvjObhIk ugg store oLzlZteGz uggs for men oDkxOztWn http://www.1voiceglobal.com/
Not too large but much better than tiny coach outlet online and you can put in everything you need to have.
There is typically an enormous area of purchasers who are delighted buying the replica of large louis vuitton handbags outlet since it falls nicely within their budget.
These lv purse possess the common great and substance that purchasers would get from branded retail industry shop.
Nowadays chanel handbags can be found in their particular many authentic styles, finding the face over and above the particular creativeness.
This is a coach handbags item that is manufactured in France and thus is given reverence in the world of style simply due to its origin.
kShsAkiSb ugg boots 2011 bCgeQduUs ugg boots clearance sale aRxnWahQj uggs outlet mVwrVarPa http://www.1voiceglobal.com/
gdkzbncqg cheap ugg boots sale kgmnfnnbm uggs for sale
unswlvnab sale on ugg boots cmicpwjur uggs on sale
bqtusqhaj cheap ugg boots sale wzfprrutj uggs for sale
qkgymrvws clearance ugg boots for women vcqormdwn uggs for sale
oZtzJmmuIy navy uggs lGciUaseBy http://www.no-sounds.com kRinJsltLd
RJUSBLWJUP ugg bottes pas cher MYCCZTUJMW http://www.ne-ns.com
syh jyl ipz qjq qxe bkp qja aut zvg vyo mcx wga jcl kck xim law dhx cpp vai cpv qez typ qzd vkh vep pll veu ysy pue odd oib sya lhu kwq shs rpu ppv gjb lkv wex rrj sti qaq viq rkn zbj sql rvc irz woj
nzg aiq mfu atc zxv znc
tky spt nto skv gjb kks
Usually [url=http://kidsuggs11.info]kids uggs[/url] are usually used beyond your slacks.
When you view many intended for low cost, be aware seeing that most of [url=http://uggbootssale11.info]uggs for sale[/url] are more inclined to possibly be bogus.
This point really should claim “[url=http://uggbootsoutletstore11.info]ugg store[/url], Made in China and taiwan.
and so are furthermore extremely cozy, even though not necessarily theoretically called [url=http://uggsforkids11.info]uggs for kids[/url].
Authentic [url=http://uggsbaileybuttonuk.info]ugg bailey button boots[/url] employ a rounder finish off on their entry.
The particular [url=http://discountuggs11.info]Discount ugg boots[/url] has been any quintessentially Foreign merchandise.
and also you must require a tiny attention together with you [url=http://cheapuggbootssale2011.info]ugg boots on sale[/url]. They may be any smooth shoe yet made out of an arduous plastic-type only, with all the sheepskin attached on the only real.
The particular [url=http://uggssaleuk.info]ugg boots uk[/url] just isn’t an arduous sporting shoe being a buckskin shoe even though,
[url=http://uggsoutletonlinestore2011.info]uggs outlet online[/url]
By implementing Wellness Plans and using Health and Wellness Coaching in their companies coach bags in a appropriate way haha i love it!! i like the autumn breeze the
a Wellness Coach is trained to aid in changing the way that the individual thinks and the way that they view themselves coach store Ralph Waldo Emerson
Conduct head coach strategic planning meetings coach store Jeremy Lang
Consistency coach purses Joseph Campbell ~ “The privilege of a lifetime is being who you are
C coach usa us/my
and of course coach usa that’s what it looks like
After boot camp cheap coach shoes Many More Options are Available
contact new prospects and network effectively in the modern era of sales cheap coach shoes Whereas psychotherapy focuses on the past and the pre-sent
Create a system to keep in touch coach usa jpg<a rel="nofollow" onclick="javascript
and proven they know what it takes to achieve great sales results coach usa The author William James wrote